Hotel
Montauk Manor
★★★★
3-Star Hotels in Montauk (NY)
18 places to stay · New York
Resort Royal Atlantic Beach Resort
★★★
Resort
Ocean Vista Resort
★★★
Resort
Ocean Surf Resort
★★★
Hotel RUSCHMEYERS
★★★
Resort
Beach Plum Resort
★★★
Motel Kenny's Tipperary Inn
★★★
Resort
Windward Shores
★★★
Hotel
Beachcomber Resort at Montauk
★★★
Hotel
A Wave Inn - Montauk
★★★
Resort Driftwood Resort on the Ocean
★★★★
Hotel
Sole East Resort
★★★
Motel
Hartman's Briney Breezes Beach Resort
★★★
Resort
Wavecrest Resort
★★★
Hotel
The Hermitage at Napeague
★★★
Motel
Breakers Montauk
★★★
Hotel
Atlantic Terrace
★★★
Serviced apartment
Offshore Spa & Residences
★★★
Loading map…
About 3-star hotels in Montauk (NY)
There are 18 3-star hotels in Montauk (NY) with a 3 to 3.5-star rating, out of 32 places to stay in the city. The most popular is Montauk Manor, rated 8.9/10 by 42 guests.
Guests' top picks in Montauk (NY): Montauk Yacht Club (9.2).
- Places to stay
- 32
- Avg. guest rating
- 8.5
- Guest reviews
- 288
- 5-star stays
- 4
Montauk (NY) hotel FAQs
How many hotels are there in Montauk (NY)?
Triptoic lists 32 places to stay in Montauk (NY), United States, including 10 resorts, 2 apartments.
What are the best-rated hotels in Montauk (NY)?
Based on guest reviews, the top-rated stays in Montauk (NY) are Montauk Yacht Club (9.2/10).
How many 5-star hotels are in Montauk (NY)?
There are 4 5-star properties in Montauk (NY).
What is the average hotel rating in Montauk (NY)?
Stays in Montauk (NY) have an average guest rating of 8.5 out of 10 (excellent), from 288 reviews in total.
Nearby destinations
More places to stay around Montauk (NY)
